Classic Tartar Sauce

This classic tartar sauce recipe transforms any seafood dish from ordinary to restaurant-quality with just minutes of prep. The creamy, tangy condiment pairs perfectly with everything from fish and chips to crab cakes, adding that perfect punch of flavor that makes seafood shine.

I first made this tartar sauce for a family fish fry when I discovered we were out of the store bought version. My husband declared it was so much better that we've never gone back to the bottled stuff in over 15 years.

Ingredients

• Mayonnaise: Forms the creamy base and provides richness to the sauce; select a good quality mayo for the best flavor
• Dill pickles: Add the signature tang and texture that defines tartar sauce; choose crisp pickles and mince them finely
• Pickle juice: Brightens the flavor and thins the sauce to the perfect consistency; save it when you use the last pickle
• Minced onion: Provides a subtle bite that balances the creaminess; look for sweet onions for a milder flavor

Step-by-Step Instructions

Combine the ingredients:

In a small bowl, add the mayonnaise first creating a base for the other ingredients. Then add the minced dill pickles, making sure they're chopped small enough to distribute throughout the sauce evenly. Pour in the pickle juice which will not only add flavor but help thin the mayonnaise to the perfect consistency. Finally, add the minced onion which provides that subtle bite that makes homemade tartar sauce special.

Mix thoroughly:

Using a spatula or spoon, fold all ingredients together gently but thoroughly. Make sure to scrape the sides and bottom of the bowl so no mayonnaise is left unmixed. Continue stirring until all the ingredients are evenly distributed throughout the sauce and no streaks remain. The texture should be creamy with small flecks of pickles and onion visible throughout.

Chill for flavor development:

Transfer the finished tartar sauce to a covered container and refrigerate for at least 2-3 hours. This resting time is crucial as it allows the flavors to meld together and the onions to mellow slightly. The sauce will thicken somewhat in the refrigerator and the flavor will become more complex and balanced.

Pin it

The humble dill pickle is truly the star of this recipe. My grandmother always insisted on hand chopping rather than using a food processor to maintain texture. She claimed that the difference between good and great tartar sauce was in those tiny chunks of pickle that burst with flavor when you bite into them.

Make It Your Own

Tartar sauce is incredibly versatile and welcomes customization. For a more complex flavor profile, consider adding a tablespoon of fresh chopped herbs like dill or parsley. Capers make an excellent addition for a more briny flavor that complements salmon beautifully. A squirt of fresh lemon juice brightens the whole sauce, while a dash of hot sauce adds unexpected heat that cuts through the richness of fried foods.

Storage Tips

While this tartar sauce will keep for up to a week in the refrigerator, its flavor is at peak perfection between 24-48 hours after making it. Store in a glass container with a tight fitting lid rather than plastic to prevent absorbing flavors from the refrigerator. If the sauce thickens too much during storage, simply stir in a teaspoon of water or additional pickle juice to bring it back to your preferred consistency.

Serving Suggestions

Traditionally paired with fish and chips, this versatile sauce extends far beyond that classic combination. Try it with crab cakes, as a spread on fish sandwiches, or as a dipping sauce for fried shrimp. For a healthier option, it makes an excellent dressing for a simple seafood salad. During summer cookouts, I set out a bowl alongside grilled fish for guests to help themselves.

Pin it

Enjoy this simple, fresh tartar sauce as the perfect complement to your favorite seafood dishes!

Frequently Asked Questions

→ How long does homemade tartar sauce last in the refrigerator?

Homemade tartar sauce will keep well in an airtight container in the refrigerator for up to one week. The flavors actually improve after the first day as ingredients meld together.

→ Can I substitute sweet pickles for dill pickles?

Yes, you can substitute sweet pickles for a sweeter tartar sauce. Keep in mind this will change the flavor profile considerably, creating a less tangy and more sweet-savory condiment.

→ What foods pair best with tartar sauce?

Tartar sauce pairs excellently with fried seafood like fish and chips, crab cakes, calamari, and fried shrimp. It also works well with fish sandwiches, as a dip for french fries, or spread on fish tacos.

→ Can I make tartar sauce without onions?

Absolutely. You can omit the onions completely or substitute with 1-2 tablespoons of finely chopped chives or green onions for a milder flavor. Some people prefer adding capers instead for a different twist.

→ Is there a way to make this tartar sauce healthier?

For a lighter version, substitute half or all of the mayonnaise with Greek yogurt. This reduces calories and fat while adding protein. You can also use light mayonnaise as an alternative.

→ How important is the chilling time for tartar sauce?

The 2-3 hour chilling time is crucial for allowing flavors to meld together. While you can use the sauce immediately after mixing, the flavor improves significantly after refrigeration, developing a more balanced and integrated taste profile.