Pin it
Nothing says summer potlucks and backyard picnics quite like a big bowl of classic creamy potato salad. This is the very recipe that has been passed around my family for years. It is everything I love about comfort food, with tender potatoes, tangy pickles, a punchy mustard dressing, and just the perfect creaminess to pull it all together.
I have made this for countless birthday BBQs and casual weeknight dinners. The leftovers are even better the next day straight from the fridge which always wins in my book.
Ingredients
- Yellow-fleshed potatoes: for their buttery texture and pretty color. Choose firm smooth potatoes with no green or sprouting
- White vinegar: to perk up the potatoes and infuse brightness. Full-strength distilled is classic here
- Large eggs: for richness and body. Fresh eggs that have been refrigerated peel most easily after cooling
- Red onion: adds gentle sharpness and crunch. Choose one that feels heavy for its size
- Celery: gives a crisp snap with every bite. Look for taut pale green stalks without dry ends
- Dill pickle: pops in some tang and savory bite. Use a firm pickle with brilliant color no rubbery ones
- Mayonnaise: for the luscious creamy base. Good quality brands or homemade are best. Miracle Whip is classic for a sweeter taste
- Yellow mustard: brightens the whole dressing. Use prepared yellow mustard for classic flavor
- Celery seeds: for aromatic depth. Fresh seeds are fragrant not dusty
- Paprika: dusted for color and a subtle warmth. Choose mild and vibrant paprika
- Salt and freshly ground black pepper: to enhance every bite. Use kosher salt for best flavor
- Fresh parsley: for garnish. Choose flat leaf parsley for its deeper taste and bright color
Instructions
- Prepare the Hard Boiled Eggs:
- Place eggs in a saucepan and cover completely with cold water by at least one inch. Bring to a full rolling boil on high heat. Once boiling set your timer for exactly seven minutes. Immediately transfer eggs to cold water once done and chill for at least thirty minutes before peeling and chopping. Proper chilling makes peeling much easier and keeps yolks from darkening.
- Cook the Potatoes:
- Peel your potatoes and cut them into equally sized chunks slightly larger than your preferred finished salad size. Place in a large pot and cover with cold water by three to four inches. Scatter in a generous pinch of salt. Bring to a boil then lower slightly but keep at an active simmer. Check doneness by sliding a sharp knife through the largest chunk. When the knife slips in with zero resistance they are ready do not overcook. Drain thoroughly.
- Season and Cool Potatoes:
- Spread drained potatoes in a large bowl. Drizzle with white vinegar right away and gently toss to distribute. Let them cool at room temperature for at least thirty minutes. This sets the texture and allows them to absorb more flavor from the vinegar.
- Make the Dressing and Prepare Additions:
- While potatoes cool chop your onion celery hard boiled eggs and pickle. In another bowl whisk together mayonnaise mustard celery seeds white vinegar paprika salt and black pepper until smooth and fully blended.
- Assemble the Salad:
- When the potatoes are cool stir in the chopped celery onions eggs and pickles. Pour dressing evenly over the mix and fold very gently until every piece is evenly coated but not mashed. Sprinkle a little paprika on top for a hint of color.
- Chill and Serve:
- Cover the salad and refrigerate for at least three hours before serving. The cooling time helps the flavors marry and firm up the texture. Just before serving top with freshly chopped parsley for a bright pop.
My grandmother always let me be the one to draw little red stripes of paprika across the top before family gatherings and it is still my favorite memory with this dish. I often sneak a little extra for color.
Storage Tips
Potato salad stays fresh for up to five days when kept refrigerated in a tightly sealed container. Always use a clean spoon to serve so it keeps its best flavor and avoids spoiling.
Ingredient Swaps and Additions
Swap yellow potatoes for red or Yukon gold for a slight change in texture. Try green onions instead of red or add chopped cooked bacon or fresh herbs for extra personality.
Serving Suggestions
Serve alongside grilled chicken or burgers or simply as an easy lunch. For picnics pack the salad in a chilled cooler and keep it covered until ready to eat.
Cultural Context
Potato salad has roots all over Europe and every family has their own signature twist. In our house yellow potatoes and a touch of Miracle Whip make it uniquely ours.
Seasonal Adaptations
For summer parties use extra fresh herbs. Try chopped snap peas or radish for fresh crunch in spring. A touch of roasted garlic can warm it up for autumn gatherings.
Helpful Notes
Salad always sets up and tastes better after chilling for at least a few hours. Choose waxy potatoes for the best shape and less mush. Slice additions small and same size for even bites.
Success Stories
My friends always request this for their birthday cookouts. Even picky eaters devour it and someone always asks for the recipe before they leave. It is the best make ahead salad I know.
Freezer Meal Conversion
Potato salad does not freeze well since the dressing separates and potatoes change texture. Enjoy it fresh within five days.
Classic creamy potato salad really is the taste of summer gatherings for my family. Make it ahead and enjoy with the people you love — it is always the first dish to disappear.
Recipe FAQs
- → How do I ensure the potatoes are tender?
Boil the potatoes until a knife slides through easily. Avoid overcooking to prevent them from becoming mushy.
- → Why add vinegar to the potatoes?
Drizzling vinegar on hot potatoes enhances their flavor and helps them soak up the dressing better.
- → Can I substitute Miracle Whip with regular mayonnaise?
Yes, use your preferred mayonnaise for a slightly less sweet, more classic flavor in the dressing.
- → How long can I store this in the fridge?
Keep the salad covered in the refrigerator for up to 5 days for best freshness and taste.
- → What’s the best way to garnish before serving?
Sprinkle with extra paprika and chopped parsley to add color and a touch of fresh flavor.
- → Is it necessary to chill the salad before serving?
Yes, chilling allows the flavors to blend and the salad to set, making it more enjoyable when served cold.